Since the Kyoto Protocol was adopted in 1997, countries have launched a series of emission-reduction measures against climate change from industrialization. But emitters at all levels — countries, regions, enterprises — need scientific data to set carbon-reduction goals and measure their results. Carbon accounting is a measure of the direct and indirect emissions of CO? and its equivalent gases from industrial activities into the Earth's biosphere. From the accounting object, carbon accounting needs at least two conditions: first, define the gases causing the greenhouse effect; second, identify the industrial activity subject.

Greenhouse gases are natural and anthropogenic gaseous components in the atmosphere that absorb and re-emit infrared radiation, including carbon dioxide (CO?), methane (CH?), nitrous oxide (N?O), hydrofluorocarbons (HFCs), perfluorocarbons (PFCs), sulfur hexafluoride (SF?) and nitrogen trifluoride (NF?). Because different gases affect the greenhouse effect differently, the IPCC proposed the concept of CO? equivalent (CO?e) to uniformly measure their environmental impact. Based on the global warming potential (GWP), we can see how each gas compares to CO?.

For energy activities and industrial production processes, according to the "Guidelines for Provincial Greenhouse Gas Inventory Compilation", HFCs, PFCs and SF? mainly involve a few industrial processes such as aluminum and magnesium, while N?O is already covered by air-pollution monitoring; thus the main objects of most enterprises' carbon accounting are CO? and CH?. According to the "2017 China Greenhouse Gas Bulletin", CO? and CH? are the primary and secondary long-lived greenhouse gases affecting the Earth's radiation balance, contributing about 66% and 17% respectively to the total radiative forcing from the increase in long-lived greenhouse gas concentrations.

From the industrial activity subject, according to the IPCC Guidelines and the provincial guidelines, carbon accounting mainly covers five activities: energy activities, industrial production, agricultural production, forestry and land-use change, and waste treatment.

For the above accounting subjects, carbon accounting can generate different types of results based on data source, measurement method, data form, data quality, measurement region and time range.

II. What are the carbon accounting methods?

Carbon accounting can mainly be divided into measurement-based and calculation-based approaches. From existing GHG emission quantification methods, there are mainly three: emission factor method, mass balance method and direct measurement method. Currently the 24 NDRC guidelines only include the emission factor and mass balance methods, but the "Administrative Measures for National Carbon Emission Trading (Trial)" issued by the MEE in December 2020 clearly states that key emitters should prioritize on-site measurement of the low calorific value and carbon content of fossil fuels.

(1) Emission factor method (calculation-based)

The emission factor method is the most widely used carbon accounting method. According to the IPCC basic equation:

GHG emissions = Activity Data (AD) × Emission Factor (EF)

AD is the activity that causes GHG emissions, such as fossil fuel consumption, limestone raw material consumption, net purchased electricity, net purchased steam, etc.; EF is the coefficient corresponding to the activity data, including carbon content per unit heating value or elemental carbon content, oxidation rate, etc., characterizing the GHG emission per unit activity. EF can directly use known data (default values) from IPCC, US EPA, European Environment Agency, etc., or be derived from representative measurements. China has set national parameters based on actual conditions; for example, Appendix 2 of the "Guidelines for GHG Emissions Accounting and Reporting for Other Industrial Enterprises (Trial)" provides default values for common fossil fuel characteristic parameters.

This method suits macro accounting at national, provincial and city levels, giving a rough macro overview of a specific region. But in practice, due to differences in regional energy quality and boiler combustion efficiency, energy consumption statistics and emission-factor measurements are prone to large deviations, which become the main source of carbon accounting errors.

(2) Mass balance method (calculation-based)

The mass balance method calculates, from the new chemicals and equipment used for national production and living each year, the share of new chemicals consumed to meet new equipment capacity or to replace removed gases. For CO?, under the carbon mass balance method, emissions equal input carbon minus non-CO? carbon output:

CO? emissions = (raw material input × raw material carbon content ? product output × product carbon content ? waste output × waste carbon content) × 44/12

where 44/12 is the conversion factor from carbon to CO? (relative atomic mass of CO? / C). Using the facility- and process-specific carbon mass balance method reflects the actual emissions at the emission site. It can distinguish differences between facilities and between individual or partial equipment. Especially when equipment is continuously updated year to year, this method is more convenient. Generally, the main enterprise carbon accounting method is the emission factor method, but in industrial production processes (such as desulfurization emissions, chemical production process emissions and other non-fossil-fuel combustion processes), the carbon balance method can be chosen as appropriate.

V. Direct measurement method

(3) Direct measurement method (measurement-based)

The direct measurement method summarizes relevant carbon emissions based on measured source data. It includes two approaches: on-site measurement and off-site measurement.

On-site measurement generally installs a carbon emission monitoring module in a CEMS to directly measure emissions by continuously monitoring concentration and flow; off-site measurement collects samples and sends them to a monitoring department for quantitative analysis with dedicated equipment and technology. Compared with each other, because off-site sampling can suffer adsorption and dissociation, on-site measurement is significantly more accurate.

The United States promotes the direct measurement method most strongly; as early as 2011 it mandated installation: the EPA's 2009 "Mandatory Greenhouse Gas Reporting Rule" requires all sources emitting more than 25,000 tons of CO?e per year to fully install CEMS and report online to the EPA from 2011.

The European Commission launched the EU ETS in 2005 and formally began monitoring CO? emissions, but currently only 155 emission units (1.5%) in 23 countries use CEMS (continuous monitoring), mainly Germany, Czech Republic and France.

Greenhouse Gas Popular Science Series

Continue reading other chapters of this series: Greenhouse Gas-1, Greenhouse Gas-2, Greenhouse Gas-3, Greenhouse Gas-4, Greenhouse Gas-5, Greenhouse Gas-6, Greenhouse Gas-7, Greenhouse Gas-8, Greenhouse Gas-9, Greenhouse Gas-10, Greenhouse Gas-11.